Is a Lower Real Estate Commission Really a Better Deal for Sellers?
When you're preparing to sell your home, it's natural to compare what different real estate agents charge. If one agent offers a lower commission, that can look like an easy way to save thousands of dollars.
And sometimes, it is.
But there's an important distinction between paying less to sell your home and actually walking away with more money.
What you keep at closing depends on several factors, including the final sale price, selling expenses, buyer concessions and the terms you negotiate.
A lower commission reduces one of those expenses. The real question is whether the overall strategy will help you achieve the best financial outcome for your situation.
After more than 25 years helping homeowners sell in Novi, Northville, South Lyon and the surrounding Metro Detroit communities, I've found that this is a conversation worth having before choosing an agent.
Real Estate Commission Is Negotiable
First, let's clear up something important.
Real estate commissions are not set by law. They are negotiable between a seller and the brokerage they hire.
Any compensation a seller chooses to offer a buyer's agent is also negotiable. It is not automatically required, and the amount and arrangement should be discussed as part of the overall selling strategy.
When you're comparing agents, you should understand exactly what each proposed fee covers and which services are included.
But I would encourage you to take the comparison one step further.
Rather than focusing exclusively on what an agent charges, consider what each agent plans to do to help you achieve your goals.
What Matters Most Is What You Keep
Selling a home involves more than finding someone willing to pay your asking price.
It involves determining the right pricing strategy, preparing and presenting the property, reaching qualified buyers, evaluating offers and negotiating the details that ultimately determine your proceeds.
Those details can include:
- The final purchase price.
- Real estate commissions and other selling expenses.
- Inspection repairs or credits.
- Appraisal-related negotiations.
- Buyer financing and the likelihood of closing.
- Closing dates and occupancy arrangements.
An agent's fee is one number you can compare upfront.
The challenge is that the final sale price and negotiated terms aren't known until the transaction is complete.
That's why I believe homeowners should evaluate both the cost of the service and the strategy behind it.
How a Lower Commission Can Affect Your Bottom Line
Let's look at a hypothetical example.
Imagine you're selling a home worth approximately $600,000 and interviewing two agents.
One proposes a lower commission. The other proposes a higher fee but presents a different pricing, marketing and negotiation strategy.
For illustration, here's what two possible outcomes could look like:
| Comparison | Lower-fee scenario | Higher-fee scenario |
|---|---|---|
| Final sale price | $600,000 | $612,000 |
| Illustrative total commission | 4% | 5% |
| Commission expense | $24,000 | $30,600 |
| Proceeds before other costs | $576,000 | $581,400 |
In this example, the seller pays $6,600 more in commission but receives $12,000 more from the sale.
The result is $5,400 more in proceeds before other closing expenses.
Of course, the opposite is also true.
If both agents achieve the same sale price and terms, the lower commission leaves the seller with more money.
These figures are hypothetical, not a prediction of what either agent would accomplish or a statement about typical commission rates. They exclude mortgage payoff, taxes, concessions and other closing expenses.
The point isn't that paying a higher commission guarantees a better result. It doesn't.
The point is that the lowest fee and the best overall financial outcome aren't necessarily the same thing.
What My Local Sales Experience Shows
One way to evaluate an agent's strategy is to examine actual sales results.
According to a review of Realcomp MLS sales in the Novi, Northville and South Lyon school districts over the most recent 12-month period, my 11 qualifying single-family listings sold for an average of 102.9% of their original asking prices.
Other qualifying single-family sales in those same districts averaged 99.6% of their original asking prices.
That's a difference worth examining, but it also deserves context.
A sale-to-list price ratio measures the relationship between the original asking price and the final sale price. It does not independently establish whether a home sold above or below its true market value.
Pricing strategy, property condition, market conditions and the characteristics of the homes being sold all influence the results.
My sample also includes just 11 transactions, so it should not be treated as a prediction of future performance.
I share the comparison because I believe homeowners should ask agents to explain their approach and support it with actual sales experience, rather than relying solely on promises.
Data source: Realcomp MLS. Residential sales excluding condominiums in the Novi, Northville and South Lyon school districts, closed November 20, 2025 through November 20, 2026. Jeff Duneske as listing agent: 11 sales averaging 102.9% of original list price. All other qualifying sales: 1,095 averaging 99.6%. Figures supplied for this article and subject to final MLS verification. Realcomp data is not verified or guaranteed.
A Recent Novi Sale: Why the Terms Matter, Too
A recent sale in Novi provides a good example of why I encourage sellers to look beyond the asking price.
We introduced the home to the market at $749,900.
The property attracted six offers and ultimately sold for $815,000, approximately 8.7% above the original asking price.
But the sale price was only part of the outcome.
The sellers also negotiated 70 days of occupancy after closing, giving them additional flexibility for their next move.
That arrangement had meaningful value because it addressed their timing needs alongside the financial terms.
Does that mean every home can sell above asking price? Absolutely not.
It also doesn't mean a sale above list price automatically represents a better result than another pricing strategy.
What it demonstrates is that evaluating offers involves more than looking at the price alone.
The strongest offer is often the one that best supports the seller's complete set of priorities.
Five Questions I'd Ask Before Choosing a Listing Agent
Whether you're considering a full-service agent or a lower-fee alternative, I recommend asking every agent the same questions.
1. How did you determine the recommended asking price?
Look for an explanation based on recent comparable sales, current competition, property condition and buyer demand.
2. What is your plan to market my home?
Ask how the property will be prepared, photographed, presented and promoted to buyers. Understand which services are included and which may cost extra.
3. How will you respond if showings or offers are slower than expected?
A thoughtful agent should be prepared to discuss market feedback, changes in competing inventory and when a pricing adjustment might be appropriate.
4. How will you handle multiple offers, inspections and appraisal concerns?
The negotiation doesn't necessarily end when you accept an offer. Ask how the agent manages challenges that arise between contract acceptance and closing.
5. What am I realistically likely to keep after selling?
Ask for a seller net proceeds estimate showing a reasonable range of sale prices, commissions, other expenses and potential concessions.
That final question may be the most important one of all.
When a Lower Commission May Be the Right Choice
There are situations where a lower-fee arrangement may be a sensible decision.
For example, you may already have a qualified buyer. Your property may require relatively limited marketing. Or you may prefer a reduced-service arrangement because you're comfortable handling some responsibilities yourself.
In those circumstances, paying for services you don't need may not make financial sense.
The important thing is understanding which responsibilities the brokerage will handle, which remain yours and how that arrangement could affect the transaction.
A higher commission doesn't automatically mean better service, stronger negotiation or a higher sale price.
Likewise, a lower commission doesn't automatically mean you're sacrificing quality.
What matters is finding the right combination of experience, service, strategy and cost for your situation.
Why Your Local Market Matters
The right selling strategy also depends on where your home is located.
In Novi, Northville and Northville Township, and South Lyon and Lyon Township, buyers may respond differently to pricing, presentation and available inventory.
Even within the same community, a home's neighborhood, condition and price range can influence the competition it faces.
That's why I start with the comparable homes and current market conditions surrounding your property, rather than relying on a citywide average or a one-size-fits-all marketing plan.
A Local Perspective from Jeff
After more than 25 years helping homeowners sell across Novi, Northville, South Lyon and the surrounding communities, I've learned that every sale comes with different priorities.
For some sellers, achieving the highest possible price is the primary goal.
For others, timing, flexibility, certainty or avoiding costly repairs may matter just as much.
That's why I believe comparing real estate agents should involve more than comparing commission rates.
You deserve to understand how each agent plans to position your home, attract qualified buyers, negotiate offers and protect your interests through closing.
A lower commission may be the right choice. A more comprehensive marketing and negotiation strategy may be worth the additional expense.
The important thing is understanding the difference before you decide.
My job is to help you understand your options, make sense of the numbers and choose a strategy that works for your situation.
If you're considering selling, I'm happy to walk you through how I would price and market your home, what expenses to expect and what you might realistically keep after closing.
You can also learn more about what to expect when selling your home with me.
Whether you decide to sell now, later or not at all, you'll have the information you need to make a confident decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is real estate commission negotiable in Michigan?
Yes. Real estate commissions are negotiable and are not established by Michigan law. Sellers should discuss the proposed fee, the services included and any potential buyer-agent compensation with their brokerage before signing a listing agreement.
Does paying a higher real estate commission mean my home will sell for more?
Not necessarily. A higher commission does not guarantee a higher sale price, and a lower commission does not automatically mean lower-quality service. Evaluate each agent's proposed strategy, relevant experience, services and track record.
How do I compare what I'll keep when selling my home?
Request an estimated seller net proceeds statement from each agent. It should account for the expected sale price, commissions, mortgage payoff, title and closing expenses, applicable taxes, potential buyer concessions and any other relevant costs. Compare estimates using consistent assumptions.
What is a sale-to-list price ratio?
A sale-to-list price ratio compares the final sale price with the original or most recent asking price, depending on which measurement is used. A ratio above 100% means a home sold above that particular list price. Because the ratio is influenced by pricing strategy, it should be evaluated alongside comparable sales and local market conditions.
When might a lower-commission agent make sense?
A lower-fee arrangement may make sense when a seller already has a buyer, needs fewer services or is comfortable managing certain responsibilities. The key is understanding exactly what services are included and whether the arrangement meets your needs.
About Jeff Duneske
Jeff Duneske is an Associate Broker with Keller Williams Advantage and has been licensed since 2000. He ranked No. 93 among individual agents in Michigan by sales volume in the 2026 RealTrends Verified rankings, based on 2025 production. Approximately 75% of his business comes from repeat clients and referrals.
A former Novi firefighter, Jeff works from downtown Northville, providing experienced real estate guidance, pricing strategy, marketing and negotiation for buyers and sellers throughout Novi, Northville, South Lyon, Brighton and the surrounding Metro Detroit communities.
Categories
- All Blogs (202)
- Best Agent For… Blog Series - Northville, Novi, South Lyon & Metro Detroit (43)
- Brighton Real Estate Market Updates (4)
- Buyers (24)
- Community & Local Events (2)
- Divorce Real Estate (11)
- Estate Planning & Strategy (7)
- Golf Course & Luxury Living (6)
- Green Oak Real Estate Market Updates (3)
- Homeowners (Maintenance & Equity) (2)
- Investors (1)
- Market Conditions (13)
- Metro Detroit Real Estate Updates (36)
- Mortgage & Financing (2)
- New Construction (3)
- Northville Real Estate Market Updates (16)
- Novi Real Estate Market Updates (19)
- Pricing & Home Values (7)
- Relocation & Moving (8)
- Rightsizing & Senior Moves (10)
- Seller Success Stories (15)
- Sellers (71)
- South Lyon Real Estate Market Updates (19)
- Tips, Guides & How-To (14)
Recent Posts









GET MORE INFORMATION


